Don't make a bad investment in Italy

We've created a guide to help you avoid pitfalls, save time, and make the best long-term investment possible.

Buying property in Italy: scams and pitfalls

Last updated on 

risks pitfalls buying real estate Italy

Everything you need to know is included in our Italy Property Pack

Italy continues to attract foreigners interested in its real estate, thanks to its rich cultural heritage and diverse property options.

Buying property in this area can be a complex journey though, particularly if you're not a local. There are many potential challenges and surprises to be aware of.

Our community of property purchasers, in conjunction with our nearby experts, has identified a multitude of problems. We've listed them all in our Italy Property Pack.

This article provides a brief overview of potential pitfalls that may arise during the property buying process in this country.

Is it safe or risky to invest in real estate in Italy?

While scams are not endemic in Italy, they can occur.

For instance, some buyers have encountered situations where properties were sold with unclear title deeds or undisclosed debts.

Additionally, in some regions, particularly in the countryside, there have been cases of properties being listed without the proper permissions or certifications for renovations.

Foreigners may sometimes face issues related to bureaucratic procedures, which can be more cumbersome and time-consuming compared to what they might be accustomed to in their home countries. Also, the language barrier can be a challenge if one is not fluent in Italian, leading to misunderstandings or misinterpretations of legal documents.

Not fully understanding the local property taxes and maintenance obligations can result in unexpected costs.

For instance, Italy has an IMU tax (a kind of municipal tax on property) that varies depending on the region and property type. Failure to understand these nuances can lead to financial strain down the line.

Italy's legal system offers solid protection for property buyers. There are stringent regulations in place governing property transactions, ensuring that both parties' rights are protected.

However, it is crucial to have a trusted notary (notaio) who can validate and oversee the property transfer.

The property buying process in Italy is relatively transparent, especially when compared to many other countries. There's a clear procedure that needs to be followed, from signing a preliminary contract to the final deed of sale.

However, as mentioned, bureaucracy can be a challenge, so patience is essential.

Italy's judicial system is known for being slow, and property disputes can take years to resolve. While the system is generally considered fair, the length of time it can take to reach a resolution is a notable drawback.

This underscores the importance of due diligence before making a purchase.

Foreign buyers should always conduct thorough due diligence. This includes ensuring the property has no outstanding debts, checking that all renovations have the necessary permissions, and confirming the legitimacy of the property title.

It's advisable to hire a local attorney experienced in real estate transactions to assist in this process.

The Italian government plays a supportive role in regulating the real estate market. Various tax incentives, especially for historic or rural properties, are often available.

However, the regulatory environment can be complex, and understanding the local nuances is crucial for foreign investors.

Some foreigners have reported challenges related to property maintenance, especially in historic districts where there are strict rules governing renovations.

Others have mentioned that understanding and navigating the local tax system can be complex.

Buying real estate in Italy can be risky

An increasing number of foreign investors are showing interest in Italy. However, 90% of them will make mistakes. Avoid the pitfalls with our comprehensive guide.

buying property foreigner Italy

Watch out for mistakes when buying property in Italy

"Diritti di superficie" or surface rights

One specific pitfall you should be aware of when buying residential property in Italy, especially as a foreigner, is the issue related to "diritti di superficie," or surface rights.

This is a uniquely Italian concept where the ownership of a property (the building itself) can be separate from the ownership of the land on which it stands.

In this context, you might find a property that seems perfect and is offered at a very attractive price, but the catch is that the land on which the property is built is not included in the sale. This means you could own the house but not the land it's on, which can lead to complications, especially when the land lease comes up for renewal.

This situation is not extremely common, but it is frequent enough that you should be vigilant. It's particularly prevalent in areas where land is scarce or highly valuable, such as in some historic city centers or coastal regions.

To avoid this pitfall, you should always ask explicitly about the ownership of both the property and the land during the initial stages of your enquiry. It's advisable to have a local property lawyer, familiar with Italian property laws and practices, to review all documents before you make any commitment or payment.

This way, you ensure that you're fully aware of what you're purchasing and avoid any unexpected future liabilities or limitations regarding the property.

The concept of "Conformità urbanistica ed edilizia"

Another unique and potentially overlooked pitfall when buying residential property in Italy involves the "conformità urbanistica ed edilizia," which refers to the urban and building conformity of the property.

In Italy, it's crucial that the property you're purchasing complies with all urban planning and building regulations, as outlined in its original approved plans.

In Italy, especially in older towns and rural areas, it's not uncommon to find properties that have been modified or extended without the necessary permits or in deviation from the original plans. This might include additions like a new room, a terrace, or even structural changes.

If you purchase a property that is not in conformity with its original plans and local regulations, you might be held responsible for bringing it back to compliance, which can be costly and time-consuming.

You should always request and review the property's "certificato di destinazione urbanistica," which is a certificate of urban destination, to ensure that the property's current state aligns with official records.

Furthermore, it's advisable to engage an experienced local architect or engineer to inspect the property and cross-verify this compliance.

This issue is particularly frequent in rural areas or in regions with many historical buildings where unauthorized modifications are more common.

Ensure that your real estate agent and legal advisor are aware that you want full clarity on this aspect to avoid any future legal and financial complications.

Don't lose money on your property in Italy

100% of people who have lost money in Italy have spent less than 1 hour researching the market. We have reviewed everything there is to know. Grab our guide now.

buying property foreigner Italy

The risks related to "usufrutto"

A less obvious but significant pitfall to be aware of when buying property in Italy is the "usufrutto" (usufruct) situation.

This is a legal right that allows someone to use and benefit from a property they do not own. Usufruct is common in Italian real estate, especially in cases where property is inherited.

In a usufruct arrangement, the owner of the property (nu-proprietario) grants the right to use the property to another person (usufruttuario) for a certain period, often until the death of the usufruttuario. This situation can be tricky for a foreign buyer, as you might purchase a property without realizing that someone else has the right to live in or use it for potentially many years.

This can occur frequently in family-owned properties, where the parents pass on the ownership of the house to their children but retain the right to live there for the rest of their lives.

If you purchase such a property, you are effectively buying the physical house but cannot use it until the usufruct expires.

To avoid this, you should always ask for a complete history of the property and verify if there are any existing usufruct agreements in place. You should check the property's registration in the local "registro immobiliare" (real estate registry) for any indications of usufruct.

It's also wise to work with a local legal advisor who can guide you through these intricacies.

"Passività occulte" or hidden liabilities

Another specific and often overlooked issue when buying property in Italy is related to "passività occulte," which translates to hidden liabilities. This refers to outstanding debts or obligations linked to the property that are not immediately apparent.

In Italy, certain debts or unpaid taxes tied to a property can legally transfer to the new owner upon purchase.

This can include unpaid condominium fees, municipal taxes, or utilities bills. The Italian legal system holds the property itself as the guarantor for these debts, meaning that when you buy a property, you could inadvertently assume responsibility for these hidden liabilities.

This issue is particularly relevant in properties that are part of a condominium (condominio), where previous owners might have left unpaid communal charges.

These charges can accumulate over time and become significant.

To safeguard against this, you should request a "visura catastale," an official real estate registry extract, for the property, which can reveal any registered liens or burdens.

Additionally, it's crucial to ask for the last few years' condominium meeting minutes, as these can indicate any outstanding issues or debts.

Moreover, involve a notary (notaio) in the purchasing process.

In Italy, the notary plays a crucial role in real estate transactions and is responsible for ensuring that the transfer of property is legally sound, including checking for any hidden liabilities.

By doing this, you can avoid the surprise of inheriting debts along with your new property.

Get the full checklist for your due diligence in Italy

Don't repeat the same mistakes others have made before you. Make sure everything is in order before signing your sales contract.

buying property foreigner Italy

Risks regarding "Vincolo idrogeologico"

Another unique aspect to consider when buying property in Italy is the "vincolo idrogeologico," which translates to hydrogeological constraint.

This is a regulation concerning properties located in areas at risk of landslides, floods, or other hydrogeological risks.

In Italy, certain areas are designated as high risk due to their geographical and environmental characteristics. If a property is within such an area, there might be strict regulations governing construction, renovation, and even maintenance.

This can significantly impact your ability to modify or even use the property as you intend.

For instance, if you buy a property in a picturesque hillside village or near a riverbank, you might face limitations on building extensions, installing certain types of infrastructure, or cultivating the land in certain ways. Ignoring these constraints can lead to legal troubles and hefty fines.

This issue is especially relevant in regions known for their scenic landscapes, such as Tuscany, Liguria, or the Amalfi Coast, where natural beauty often coincides with environmental vulnerability.

To avoid complications, you should inquire about any hydrogeological constraints before purchasing. This can be done by consulting the local municipality's "piano regolatore generale" (general regulatory plan) or the "piano di assetto idrogeologico" (hydrogeological setting plan), which outline the land use regulations for different areas.

Additionally, seeking advice from a local environmental engineer or a geologist can provide insights into any potential risks or limitations associated with the property.

This extra step in due diligence can save you from future legal and financial headaches.

"Diritti di passaggio" or right of way

An additional unique aspect to consider when buying property in Italy is the issue of "diritti di passaggio," or right of way.

This is particularly relevant in rural or historical areas where properties often have ancient and complex arrangements regarding access.

In Italy, many properties, especially older ones in rural locations, may not have direct access to a public road. They might be accessible only through a neighboring property. In such cases, a legal right of way (easement) is established, allowing the property owner to cross another person's land to reach their own.

However, this right might not always be formally recorded or may be based on longstanding but informal local agreements.

For example, if you purchase a countryside villa or a farmhouse, you may discover that the only access road passes through someone else's property. If this right of passage isn't legally established, you could face access issues in the future, especially if relationships with neighboring property owners change.

Engaging a local lawyer who understands the nuances of Italian property law is essential.

They can help you navigate these complexities and ensure that any necessary easements are legally recognized and protected, safeguarding your access to the property.

Don't sign an Italian document you don't understand

Buying a property in Italy? We have reviewed all the documents you need to know. Stay out of trouble - grab our comprehensive guide.

buying property foreigner Italy

"Accatastamento" or the cadastral registration process

Yet another specific issue to be mindful of when buying property in Italy is the challenge of "accatastamento," or the cadastral registration process.

In Italy, every property must be correctly registered in the "Catasto," the land registry, which includes detailed records of the property's size, use, and boundaries.

The problem arises when there are discrepancies between the actual state of the property and its official registration in the Catasto. For example, previous owners might have carried out modifications, extensions, or renovations without updating the cadastral records. This is a common issue in older properties or those that have been in families for generations.

If you purchase a property with inaccurate or outdated cadastral data, rectifying these discrepancies can be a lengthy and costly process. It might involve legal proceedings, architectural surveys, and negotiations with local authorities.

Furthermore, until these issues are resolved, you might face difficulties in using the property as intended, especially if you plan significant renovations or extensions.

"Vincoli storici e artistici" or historical and artistic constraints

Another unique and potentially problematic aspect to be aware of when purchasing property in Italy involves "vincoli storici e artistici," which are historical and artistic constraints.

This is particularly relevant for properties that are located in historical centers or that are of historical and cultural significance.

In Italy, there is a strong emphasis on preserving the historical and cultural heritage.

Properties that fall under this category may be subject to strict regulations overseen by the "Soprintendenza Belle Arti e Paesaggio" (Superintendency of Fine Arts and Landscape).

These regulations can significantly limit what changes can be made to the property, including renovations, restorations, and even minor alterations like the color of the exterior paint or the type of windows you can install.

For instance, if you buy a property in a historic town center, such as in Florence, Rome, or Venice, you might find that your ability to modify the property is limited.

These constraints are put in place to preserve the aesthetic and cultural integrity of historically significant areas.

To navigate this, it's crucial to inquire about any historical or artistic constraints before purchasing.

You can do this by consulting local urban planning offices or the Soprintendenza. Understanding these constraints upfront is important, as non-compliance can lead to hefty fines and the requirement to reverse any unauthorized changes.

Moreover, involve an architect or a surveyor who specializes in historical properties.

They can guide you on what modifications are permissible and help in obtaining the necessary approvals for any renovation work.

This due diligence is essential to ensure that your investment in Italian real estate is not hampered by unforeseen regulatory restrictions.

Thinking of buying real estate in Italy?

Acquiring property in a different country is a complex task. Don't fall into common traps – grab our guide and make better decisions.

buying property foreigner Italy

The issue of "agibilità"

A further unique consideration when buying property in Italy is the issue of "agibilità," or the habitability certificate.

This certificate is a crucial document that certifies a property is safe and meets the necessary health, safety, and structural standards set by Italian law.

In Italy, especially in older properties or those that have undergone significant renovations, there is a risk that the property might not have an updated habitability certificate. This can happen if previous owners made modifications to the property without obtaining the necessary permits or inspections.

Without this certificate, you might face challenges in legally inhabiting the property, and it could also affect your ability to connect to essential services like electricity and water.

For example, if you purchase a rustic farmhouse or a historic city apartment, you must ensure that it has a valid agibilità certificate that reflects its current state. The absence of this certificate can lead to legal complications and additional costs to bring the property up to the required standards.

Before finalizing your purchase, ask for the property's agibilità certificate and verify its validity and congruence with the property's current condition.

It's advisable to have a professional, such as an engineer or architect, assess whether the property complies with the standards required for the certificate.

In summary, ensuring the presence and accuracy of the habitability certificate is key to avoiding legal and practical issues in your Italian property purchase.

This step ensures that the property is legally recognized as suitable for living and complies with all necessary safety and health regulations.

"Zone agricole" or agricultural zoning

An additional unique aspect to consider when purchasing property in Italy is the issue of "zone agricole," or agricultural zoning.

This is particularly relevant if you are looking to buy property in rural areas or are interested in purchasing land that includes farmland or vineyards.

In Italy, agricultural land is often subject to specific regulations and restrictions regarding its use and development. These regulations are designed to protect agricultural activities and the rural landscape. If you buy a property that includes agricultural land, you may find that you are limited in terms of what you can build or change on that land.

For instance, constructing new buildings or converting the land for non-agricultural use can be challenging and often requires special permissions.

Moreover, in some cases, local agricultural consortia or neighboring farmers may have preemptive rights to purchase agricultural land before it can be sold to others, especially to non-farmers or foreigners.

This can complicate the buying process.

To navigate this complexity, you should first verify the zoning status of the property and understand the specific restrictions and obligations that come with owning agricultural land in Italy.

It's important to check with the local municipality ("Comune") to understand the zoning regulations and any potential restrictions on land use.

Additionally, consulting with a local lawyer or real estate expert who understands the nuances of agricultural property in Italy is crucial.

They can help ensure that you are fully aware of and compliant with all relevant regulations and restrictions, and can assist in navigating any legal complexities related to agricultural land ownership.

Make a profitable investment in Italy

Better information leads to better decisions. Save time and money. Download our guide.

buying property foreigner Italy