Should you still buy in Granton if the tram is delayed?

See what went wrong for property buyers in Edinburgh

Is the Granton tram really delayed, or could it disappear altogether?

The Granton tram is in much more trouble than a normal delay: council officers currently recommend putting the northern extension on a strategic pause, with no reliable opening date buyers can use.

Edinburgh has been studying a north-south tram line connecting Granton with the city centre and continuing south toward the Royal Infirmary and BioQuarter. The Granton section ran into a basic problem: neither of the main routes came out looking easy.

The route through the Roseburn Path was cheaper and quicker, but the consultation exposed strong opposition over the impact on a heavily used walking and cycling corridor. The alternative through Orchard Brae and Dean Bridge avoided much of that fight but came with a much bigger construction bill and harder engineering.

The latest Strategic Business Case has therefore changed the practical outlook. Council officers want the city to concentrate first on the southern tram extension and pause the Granton section while wider regional transport work continues. Councillors still have to make the formal decision, so saying that Granton has already lost its tram would go too far. For a property buyer, though, the sensible assumption is simple: there is no dependable Granton tram timetable.

Option	Estimated cost in earlier council work	Forecast annual passengers	Peak trip to city centre	Where it stands now
Granton via Roseburn	£350m-£480m for northern section	~4.1m	~26 minutes	Strong opposition; officers recommend a pause
Granton via Orchard Brae	£650m-£850m for northern section	~3.7m	~34 minutes	More expensive and technically harder
Southern Edinburgh extension	About £1.7bn in latest project work	Part of wider network case	Not relevant to Granton	Current priority
Granton mass transit longer term	No committed cost or opening date	Demand case remains	Unknown	Further regional work needed

Does buying in Granton still make sense without the tram?

Yes. Granton can still work without a tram, but we would buy it as a regeneration-and-value story rather than a transport speculation.

That is a tougher test, and the right one.

The waterfront programme already goes far beyond a proposed tram stop. Edinburgh's wider plan is for roughly 3,500 homes, around 16 hectares of green space, commercial and cultural uses, a school, low-carbon infrastructure and a substantial redevelopment of former industrial land.

Several pieces are already visible. Granton Station View is occupied. Western Villages has brought hundreds of homes and a large new resident population. The restored gasholder has opened as a public park. Silverlea is adding another 143 affordable homes. The next big phase has approval for 847 homes.

That changes the investment case quite a lot. Five years ago, a buyer could reasonably worry that Granton was mostly a masterplan attached to empty development land. Today, enough has happened on the ground that we can judge the area without pretending the tram has to rescue it.

We would still give a future tram some value, but only as upside. A purchase that needs the line to arrive within the next five or six years is now too speculative.

How much of Granton Waterfront has actually been built?

Granton Waterfront is still years from completion, but enough has been delivered that calling the regeneration hypothetical no longer makes sense.

Western Villages is the clearest example. The council said recently that 388 social and mid-market rental homes there were largely occupied, housing around 1,400 people. Granton Station View has another 75 occupied energy-efficient homes, while construction is well underway on 143 affordable homes at Silverlea.

The next jump is much larger. The approved Phase 1 plan contains 847 homes alongside commercial space, green areas, active-travel infrastructure and room for the new primary school.

Physical improvements have moved as well. The historic Granton Station has been restored, while the former gas holder has become a 1.2-hectare public park. These are relatively small compared with the full £1.3 billion masterplan, but they matter because buyers can already see part of the neighbourhood taking shape.

We are still buying into a construction zone rather than a finished district. The difference is that Granton has moved well past the point where everything depends on future promises.

Development	Scale	Current position	Why it matters
Granton Station View	75 homes	Occupied	One completed residential piece
Western Villages	388 rental homes reported occupied	Largely occupied	Around 1,400 residents already added
Silverlea	143 homes	Under construction	Further affordable housing underway
Gasholder 1	1.2-hectare park	Open	Gives the waterfront a real public destination
Phase 1	847 homes plus commercial space	Approved and moving forward	Much larger next stage of the neighbourhood
Full Granton Waterfront	Around 3,500 homes	Long-term programme	Changes Granton at district scale

Could the tram pause derail the rest of Granton Waterfront?

For now, Granton Waterfront is still moving independently of the tram, so a transport pause does not look capable of freezing the whole regeneration.

That is one of the more reassuring findings here. Housing delivery is already happening through separate funding, planning and development agreements.

The council has approved the business case for the next waterfront phase and is working with Cruden on the 847-home scheme. Scottish Government infrastructure funding has also been committed to the area, including almost £16 million through the Housing Infrastructure Fund and a broader package that can support roads, utilities and the low-carbon heat network.

The school is another useful test. Edinburgh Council is currently consulting on the new Granton Waterfront primary school, with completion expected around 2029 if planning proceeds. That timetable is moving separately from the tram decision.

Cultural investment is following its own route too. National Galleries of Scotland's Art Works project is planned for Granton and has already secured substantial heritage funding.

There is still execution risk. A regeneration this large can slow down, phases can change and private development can respond to the housing market. But the evidence does not support treating a paused tram as a pause button for Granton itself.

Is Granton still cheap compared with Edinburgh?

Yes. Granton remains clearly cheaper than Edinburgh overall, and that discount is one of the best reasons to keep looking there despite the tram uncertainty.

The exact figure depends on the dataset. Rightmove's latest sold-price series puts the average Granton sale over the past year at about £235,500, with flats averaging roughly £216,400. ESPC's more recent six-month Granton data gives an average selling price of around £222,900.

For Edinburgh as a whole, ESPC recently recorded an average selling price close to £296,000. We should not compare those numbers as though every property were identical because Granton has a different mix of flats and houses, but the discount is too large to dismiss as statistical noise.

Newhaven offers an even more useful comparison. Its latest ESPC average has been running around £250,000-£265,000 depending on the measurement period. Newhaven already has the tram, established amenities and much closer links with Leith.

So Granton currently offers a genuine discount to a nearby northern waterfront area that is further along in its development.

That does not guarantee convergence. It simply means buyers have not already priced Granton like a finished tram-connected waterfront neighbourhood.

Area / measure	Recent average	Rough premium to Granton	What we learn
Granton, ESPC recent six-month period	~£222,900	—	Useful current local benchmark
Granton, Rightmove last year	~£235,500	—	Broader sold-price measure
Granton flats, Rightmove	~£216,400	—	Relevant for apartment buyers
Newhaven, recent ESPC periods	~£250,000-£265,000	roughly 12%-19%	More established waterfront + tram
Edinburgh overall, recent ESPC report	~£295,600	roughly 25%-33%	Shows Granton's broader affordability gap

Are Granton prices already assuming the regeneration will succeed?

No. Granton prices have risen lately, but we are not seeing the sort of speculative surge that would suggest buyers have already priced in a finished waterfront and a future tram.

Rightmove's latest figures put Granton sold prices about 3% above the previous year. ESPC has also recently highlighted Granton as one of Edinburgh's more affordable areas seeing healthy transaction activity.

That looks more like normal demand for cheaper Edinburgh housing than a regeneration frenzy.

The exception is new-build stock. Granton contains a huge spread between older resales and new apartments with strong energy ratings, balconies and waterfront views. At West Shore, recent two-bedroom asking prices have ranged from around £255,000 to £295,000, with some units previously marketed above £300,000.

One £295,000 two-bedroom apartment was recently reduced from £305,000. Another £255,000 unit was being sold with a 5% deposit contribution and a flooring package.

Those incentives are useful evidence. Developers do not usually offer contributions when buyers are fighting over every remaining unit. They suggest the upper end of Granton's new-build market already needs a bit more persuasion than the regeneration story alone might imply.

Is a Granton new-build still worth paying extra for?

Sometimes, but we would be much less willing to pay a large Granton new-build premium purely for future neighbourhood improvements.

Take the roughly £216,400 average price of Granton flats from Rightmove as a rough reference point. A £255,000 new-build sits around 18% above it. At £295,000, the premium is approximately 36%.

That comparison is imperfect because a new West Shore apartment can be substantially better than an older local flat. The development has very strong energy performance, modern insulation, balconies on many units and contemporary layouts. A good Forth view also carries real value.

The problem comes when the buyer pays £290,000 or £300,000 for an ordinary unit and then quietly assumes that the tram, new shops, cultural attractions and wider waterfront will make today's premium look cheap.

With the Granton tram facing a strategic pause, we would want more of that future upside left in the purchase price.

A £255,000 unit with excellent energy performance, a useful layout and a good position can still make sense. Around £300,000, we become much more selective.

Example purchase price	Premium over ~£216,400 Granton flat average	Rent needed for 6% gross yield	How demanding is the price?
£216,000 resale	roughly 0%	~£1,080/month	Current fundamentals can do most of the work
£255,000 new-build	~18%	~£1,275/month	Reasonable if the unit is genuinely better
£265,000 new-build	~22%	~£1,325/month	Needs good specification and location
£295,000 new-build	~36%	~£1,475/month	Much harder to justify with average local rents
£315,000 new-build	~46%	~£1,575/month	Heavy reliance on premium future demand

Can you live in Granton comfortably without the tram?

Yes. Granton already has workable bus links into central Edinburgh, although frequent commuters lose much more from the tram delay than hybrid workers do.

Granton is served by several Lothian bus routes running toward the city centre and other parts of Edinburgh. Depending on the exact starting point and traffic, central journeys can be reasonably quick.

The weakness is predictability. A tram would give Granton a high-capacity route that is less exposed to normal road congestion. Buses can serve today's neighbourhood, but several thousand additional homes will eventually put more pressure on local transport.

That distinction changes the value of the tram for different buyers. Someone commuting into central Edinburgh five days a week should put a fairly high price on reliable mass transit. A hybrid worker making the journey twice a week may care much more about purchase price, space and the waterfront.

The current bus network is good enough that Granton can function without a tram. We simply would not value its connectivity as though Newhaven-style transport had already arrived.

Did Edinburgh's Newhaven tram actually push property prices up?

The Newhaven extension probably helped nearby property prices, but the latest evidence gives us no credible basis for assuming Granton would automatically get a 20% or 30% tram windfall.

ESPC recently compared selling prices around the Newhaven extension with levels immediately before the line opened. The changes were striking in a few places: around Leith Walk, average prices were up about 37%; Brunswick was up 30%; and Pilrig was up 25%.

Move slightly farther out and the story becomes much less dramatic. Leith as a whole increased only around 5%. Newhaven itself also rose roughly 5%, from about £247,500 before the extension to around £260,700 three years later. The Shore increased around 10%.

That range is more useful than any single headline number. The biggest gains occurred in particular micro-markets where transport improvement arrived alongside wider neighbourhood demand and regeneration. Even ESPC cautioned that the tram cannot explain the entire increase.

So we do think a Granton tram could eventually help values. We would never put "+30%" into a Granton investment spreadsheet today.

Area near Newhaven tram extension	Approx. price change over three years	What it tells us
Leith Walk	+37%	Very strong micro-location performance
Brunswick	+30%	Large gain near central tram stops
Pilrig	+25%	Strong result, but other local factors also matter
The Shore	+10%	Positive but far less dramatic
Leith overall	+5%	Tram effect is clearly not uniform
Newhaven	+5%	Direct tram access did not produce an automatic 20%-30% jump

Could 3,500 new Granton homes hold property prices back?

Yes. Granton's huge housing pipeline can improve the neighbourhood while keeping a lid on the price of ordinary flats.

This is one of the more underappreciated risks in the Granton story.

The full waterfront plan contains around 3,500 homes. Western Villages, Granton Station View and Silverlea account for only part of that total, while Phase 1 alone adds another 847.

Every new resident helps Granton. More people support cafés, shops, schools, transport services and local businesses. A fuller waterfront should feel safer, busier and more useful than large stretches of redevelopment land.

Property investors still face the other side of the equation: new apartments create competition.

Imagine selling an ordinary two-bedroom flat five years from now. A buyer may be choosing between your unit, another resale nearby and a brand-new apartment with better insulation, a warranty, incentives and lower heating bills. Unless your property has a view, stronger location, more space or a lower price, the regeneration can make the neighbourhood better without making your particular flat scarce.

That is why entry price matters so much in Granton. Buying the area is easy. Buying something that remains attractive once thousands of newer homes exist is harder.

Does a Granton buy-to-let still make money today?

Yes, particularly at resale prices, but Granton rental yields become much less exciting when the purchase price approaches £300,000.

Current Citylets listings show ordinary two-bedroom Granton apartments around £1,200-£1,300 per month, with examples around £1,325, £1,450 and higher for better modern or waterfront units. Citylets' wider local asking-rent data recently put two-bedroom flats around £1,350 per month.

At a £216,000 purchase price, £1,300 a month gives a gross yield of roughly 7.2%. At £265,000, it falls to around 5.9%. At £295,000, the same rent produces only about 5.3%.

A particularly good waterfront flat can rent higher. One recent Lower Granton Road two-bedroom listing with panoramic sea views was asking £1,750 per month. We would not use that as the baseline for a normal apartment.

And these are gross figures. Factoring charges, maintenance, insurance, void periods, management, mortgage interest and tax all come afterward.

The cleanest Granton rental proposition is still a reasonably priced resale with rent supported by today's market. Once we pay a substantial new-build premium, appreciation starts doing more of the financial work.

Purchase price	£1,200 monthly rent	£1,300 monthly rent	£1,450 monthly rent
£216,000	6.7% gross	7.2% gross	8.1% gross
£255,000	5.6%	6.1%	6.8%
£265,000	5.4%	5.9%	6.6%
£295,000	4.9%	5.3%	5.9%

Will Granton actually become a much nicer place to live?

Yes. Granton's physical improvement looks more convincing than the tram story, and that is where we would put most of our confidence.

The gasholder park is already open. Hundreds of new homes are occupied. Phase 1 is designed to add shops, leisure space, more green areas and active-travel routes.

The new primary school is becoming more concrete too. Edinburgh Council is currently consulting on the design and expects completion around 2029 if the project receives approval. That matters more for long-term owner-occupier demand than another architectural rendering of the waterfront.

National Galleries of Scotland's planned Art Works facility adds another layer. The project is intended to house and provide access to a large part of the national collection while creating visitor, research and community spaces in Granton.

These projects will not turn Granton into Leith overnight. Restaurants, independent businesses and street activity tend to appear after residents arrive rather than before them.

Still, the direction is fairly easy to see. Someone buying for eight or ten years can reasonably expect to live in a more complete neighbourhood than the one that exists today even if no tram rails have been laid by then.

What Granton properties would we actually buy now?

We would favour a well-priced Granton resale or a genuinely distinctive new-build that already works on today's transport, rent and neighbourhood conditions.

For a resale, we want a meaningful discount to new construction. The property then has room to benefit from the wider regeneration without requiring every masterplan promise to arrive on schedule.

A genuine Forth or harbour view helps because developers cannot manufacture unlimited waterfront positions. A good balcony, sensible layout, strong natural light, secure parking where useful and low running costs also make a flat easier to distinguish from the thousands of homes coming later.

Location within Granton matters more than the postcode alone. A property already close to buses, supermarkets, the waterfront and completed public space carries less development risk than one surrounded by land that still needs to be transformed.

With new-builds, we would pay close attention to incentives. A developer offering a deposit contribution, flooring package or price reduction is telling us something about the level at which buyers need convincing. Those offers can make a deal better, but they should also stop us from assuming every fixed asking price represents a hard market value.

The property we would be most reluctant to buy is a generic two-bedroom apartment at the expensive end of Granton's range with no exceptional view or layout. Too much future progress is already embedded in that price.

Who should avoid buying in Granton right now?

Short-term buyers, tram speculators and anyone stretching to pay a large new-build premium should be especially careful with Granton.

The clearest mismatch is a buyer expecting a quick infrastructure catalyst. The proposed northern tram line has moved in the wrong direction for that strategy, and there is no reliable date around which to build a three- or five-year trade.

A buyer who already dislikes Granton's present amenities also needs patience. The neighbourhood is improving, but large parts will remain unfinished for years. Buying because you love what Granton may become is very different from enjoying what exists outside the front door this weekend.

Investors at the top end of new-build pricing face a similar problem. If a £295,000 flat earns roughly the same rent as something meaningfully cheaper nearby, much of the return depends on future buyers paying an even higher premium.

The strongest Granton buyer is almost the opposite: someone with a long horizon, comfortable with current bus transport, able to buy below the area's most ambitious new-build pricing and willing to let the regeneration unfold slowly.

Should you still buy in Granton if the tram is delayed?

Yes, but we would only buy in Granton if the deal still looks good after assuming there is no tram for many years.

That single test removes most of the confusion.

The tram outlook has clearly deteriorated. Council officers are recommending a strategic pause for the Granton section, and the southern extension is taking priority. A buyer should therefore stop treating a near-term tram as part of the property's current value.

Granton still has enough going for it. Housing is being delivered. Hundreds of new homes are occupied. The gasholder park is open. Another 847-home phase is moving forward. The school is progressing through consultation. Granton remains substantially cheaper than Edinburgh overall, while recent local sales data shows demand without anything resembling speculative overheating.

The weak point is supply. Around 3,500 planned homes mean an ordinary flat can easily face newer competition later. That makes the exact property and purchase price more important than having "Granton Waterfront" in the address.

We would be comfortable buying a good resale around current local values, particularly where the flat has a view, strong layout or another durable advantage. A new-build can work too, but once the price gets close to £300,000 we want a very clear reason for paying the premium.

The delayed tram has made Granton more selective rather than unbuyable.

Buy Granton because the property is good value today and the neighbourhood is already improving. If a tram eventually arrives, take the extra upside.

If the purchase only looks attractive after assuming the tram comes, we would leave it alone.

Who is the author of this content?

INVESTROPA

A team researching how property purchases actually go wrong across Europe

We are a team of real estate researchers and local specialists focused on helping people avoid expensive mistakes when buying property abroad, particularly in Edinburgh. If you’d like to learn more about us, you can check our presentation page.