Is Airbnb still profitable in Edinburgh?

Get all the data you need about the real estate market in Edinburgh

Is Airbnb in Edinburgh still profitable today?

Yes, a good Edinburgh Airbnb can still make serious money today, but buying an ordinary flat specifically to turn it into a short-term let has become a much harder investment to justify.

The city still gives hosts something many Airbnb markets struggle to offer: large volumes of international tourism, high nightly rates and extraordinary peaks around the festivals. AirDNA's latest Edinburgh data puts average occupancy at 68%, the average daily rate at about $268 and average annual listing revenue at $56,300, roughly £41,500 at current exchange rates.

Those numbers alone make Edinburgh look exceptionally attractive. The problem appears when we put them beside everything an investor now has to deal with. The whole city is a short-term-let control area. A secondary whole-home let normally needs planning permission as well as a licence. Scotland charges an 8% Additional Dwelling Supplement when it applies. The old furnished-holiday-let tax advantages have disappeared. Edinburgh now also has a 5% visitor levy on eligible stays.

So profitability still exists, but it has become concentrated in properties that already have the right legal setup, unusually strong revenue potential or both. For someone starting from scratch, getting permission to run the Airbnb can now be harder than making the Airbnb itself profitable.

Edinburgh Airbnb metric	Latest reading	Recent change	What we take from it
Active listings	7,528	-28.3% YoY	Considerably less active supply
Average occupancy	68%	-0.8% YoY	Still strong, but not improving
Average daily rate	$268	-5.8% YoY	Hosts are getting slightly less per booked night
RevPAR	$183	-6.1% YoY	Underlying revenue performance has softened
Average annual revenue	$56,300	+55.6% YoY	Needs careful interpretation because the listing pool changed heavily
Licensed/provisional properties in operation	3,209	—	Regulation has reduced the pool of straightforward legal operators

Is Edinburgh Airbnb demand still strong?

Yes, Edinburgh still has excellent short-term-rental demand, although the latest official numbers show that demand has stopped growing.

VisitScotland recorded 5.05 million overnight tourism trips inside the City of Edinburgh in 2024, producing 17.79 million visitor nights and £2.565 billion of spending. That works out to about £508 of spending for every overnight trip.

Short-term accommodation captures a large part of that market. The Office for National Statistics counted just over 3.0 million guest nights in Edinburgh through Airbnb, Booking.com and Expedia in 2024. Only Westminster and Cornwall recorded more among UK local authorities. Edinburgh alone represented 26.5% of all Scottish platform guest nights.

International visitors make the market particularly valuable. They accounted for 67.4% of Edinburgh's short-term-let guest nights, the highest proportion among major UK destinations outside London.

But Edinburgh Airbnb is not booming right now. The ONS's latest rolling period, covering the twelve months to June 2025, recorded 3.03 million Edinburgh guest nights, down 1.4% from 3.07 million a year earlier. Scotland overall grew 5.5% over the same period, and Edinburgh was the only local authority among the UK's top 15 short-term-let destinations where guest nights fell.

Demand remains huge. Growth, for now, has flattened.

If Edinburgh tourism is so strong, why aren't Airbnb results improving?

Edinburgh Airbnb hosts currently have plenty of guests to compete for, but the latest performance numbers show that strong tourism is no longer automatically pushing nightly prices or occupancy higher.

AirDNA reports 68% occupancy, down 0.8% year on year. Its average daily rate has fallen 5.8% to $268, while RevPAR has dropped 6.1% to $183. The ONS independently found that Edinburgh platform guest nights slipped 1.4% in its latest comparable twelve-month period.

That combination tells us more than tourist arrivals alone. Edinburgh remains one of Britain's biggest short-term-rental destinations, yet hosts are operating in a market where room performance has softened a little.

The strange figure is AirDNA's average annual revenue, which is up 55.6% to $56,300 even while occupancy, nightly rates and RevPAR are down. We would not treat that as evidence that the typical unchanged Edinburgh Airbnb suddenly earns 56% more.

Active listings fell 28.3% over the same period. With such a large change in the properties included in the dataset, the average revenue figure is being calculated from a very different pool of listings. The surviving properties may also be available for different numbers of nights or skewed toward stronger professional operators.

For an investment model, the current ADR, occupancy, comparable properties and actual availability calendar deserve far more weight than the headline 55.6% revenue increase.

AirDNA measure	YoY change	What it suggests
Occupancy	-0.8%	Demand per available listing has barely weakened
Average daily rate	-5.8%	Pricing has softened
RevPAR	-6.1%	Underlying earning power per available night has fallen
Active listings	-28.3%	The market's supply pool changed dramatically
Average annual revenue	+55.6%	Cannot safely be read as same-property revenue growth

How seasonal is Airbnb in Edinburgh?

Edinburgh Airbnb is highly seasonal, and August can make an ordinary annual return look spectacular for a few weeks.

ONS data show 411,900 Edinburgh short-term-let guest nights in August 2024 compared with only 111,820 in January. August attracted roughly 3.7 times the January traffic.

The scale of that festival effect becomes clearer when we look at the whole year. An evenly distributed month would account for 8.3% of annual demand. August generated 13.6% by itself, while January contributed only 3.7%.

That creates huge pricing opportunities during the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, Edinburgh International Festival and surrounding summer events. It also makes optimistic Airbnb projections particularly easy to produce. A host who uses August rates as a reference for the rest of the year will badly overestimate revenue.

The strongest Edinburgh Airbnbs can use the festival period to make a disproportionate share of their annual profit. We still want the investment to work during the other eleven months.

Period	Edinburgh platform guest nights	Share of annual total
January	111,820	3.7%
Average month if demand were even	~251,000	8.3%
August	411,900	13.6%
August versus January	3.7x	—

Has Edinburgh's Airbnb crackdown actually reduced supply?

Yes, Edinburgh's short-term-let crackdown has coincided with a very large reduction in active Airbnb supply.

AirDNA currently counts 7,528 active short-term-rental listings, 28.3% fewer than a year earlier. That is a far bigger movement than the 0.8% fall in occupancy or the 1.4% decline in ONS guest nights, so the change cannot simply be explained by tourists disappearing.

The official licensing numbers tell the same story from another angle. Scottish Government statistics counted 3,209 granted or provisional short-term-let licences in operation in Edinburgh at the end of 2025. Edinburgh also accounted for 54 of Scotland's 63 temporary licences and all 128 temporary exemptions, mainly because the Festival creates unusual short-duration accommodation demand.

AirDNA listings and government licences should not be compared one-for-one because they measure different things. A listing database can contain rooms, temporarily available homes and multiple platform listings, while the licensing statistics count licences. Still, the direction is clear: Edinburgh has moved away from the much looser short-term-let market that existed before licensing and planning controls tightened.

That can help the operators who remain. Losing almost three listings in every ten reduces competition. But the same rules that protect established operators also make it harder for a new investor to join them.

Can you still buy a normal Edinburgh flat and turn it into an Airbnb?

Sometimes, but buying a normal Edinburgh flat today with the assumption that Airbnb permission will follow is a very risky strategy.

The entire City of Edinburgh has been a short-term-let control area since 2022. When a dwelling that is not the owner's principal home is changed into a whole-property short-term let, Edinburgh normally treats that as a material change of use requiring planning permission.

Licensing comes on top of that. Anyone operating short-term accommodation normally needs a short-term-let licence, and secondary letting has its own licence category.

This catches buyers out because an attractive flat can work perfectly on an Airbnb spreadsheet while failing at the planning stage. Edinburgh contains enormous numbers of tenement flats accessed through communal stairs, exactly the kind of residential environment where planning concerns about noise, arrivals, departures and neighbour disturbance become harder to overcome.

Main-home hosting is a different proposition. Home sharing and limited home letting of someone's principal residence do not normally face the same planning requirement. The biggest regulatory problem sits with investors buying secondary properties specifically for full-time tourist use.

In Edinburgh these days, planning due diligence belongs at the beginning of the buying process, not somewhere near the end.

Are shared-stair flats a bad bet for a new Edinburgh Airbnb?

Yes, an ordinary residential flat reached through a shared tenement stair is one of the weakest candidates for a new Edinburgh Airbnb.

That matters more here than in many cities because traditional tenement flats make up a huge part of Edinburgh's housing stock. The planning objection is straightforward: tourists repeatedly arriving and leaving through the same communal entrance can affect neighbours in a way that a self-contained property with its own door may not.

Edinburgh has been refusing this kind of short-term-let conversion for years, and appeals have repeatedly tested the same problem. Industry groups representing self-catering operators have themselves highlighted shared-stair refusals as one of the biggest threats facing Edinburgh hosts.

A shared stair does not make approval mathematically impossible. Existing lawful-use cases and unusual building circumstances can produce different outcomes. But a buyer should never price a residential tenement flat on the assumption that planning permission for a new secondary Airbnb is routine.

The safer properties are those where the legal short-term-let position is already established or where the building and existing use are much more compatible with visitor accommodation.

Is an existing Edinburgh Airbnb much more valuable than a flat with no permission?

For an Airbnb investor, an Edinburgh property with a secure existing legal short-term-let position can be dramatically more useful than an otherwise similar flat with no planning history.

The furniture, photographs and Airbnb reviews are easy to replace. Planning status is much harder to recreate.

Some properties that were already operating before Edinburgh became a control area may have an established planning position or a certificate of lawfulness. Others may have explicit planning permission for short-term accommodation. A new buyer needs to establish exactly what exists and whether continued operation remains lawful after the sale.

The licence is another separate check. Edinburgh explicitly says planning and licensing are different requirements, so seeing a licence number does not answer every planning question.

Title deeds, mortgage terms and insurance also matter. Edinburgh Council itself tells prospective hosts to check whether title conditions restrict short-term letting and whether the proposed use is compatible with their mortgage and insurance arrangements.

An investor paying a premium for an "Airbnb property" should therefore be paying for demonstrable legal operating rights and earning history. Paying extra simply because the seller previously listed the flat online would be dangerous.

How much can an Edinburgh Airbnb realistically earn?

A successful Edinburgh Airbnb can still generate gross revenue around £40,000 a year, and stronger properties can go considerably higher, but we would not use one city-wide average as a promise for a specific flat.

AirDNA currently reports $56,300 of average annual revenue per active Edinburgh listing, roughly £41,500 using current exchange rates. Its $268 average daily rate is roughly £198.

Those figures are believable in a city where occupancy remains around 68% and August demand is exceptional. They also hide enormous variation. A compact flat outside the strongest visitor areas, a premium Old Town property sleeping six people and a large Festival-oriented apartment are fundamentally different businesses.

The latest AirDNA revenue figure also deserves the caution discussed earlier because active supply has contracted 28.3% while RevPAR is down. For underwriting, we would rather construct several revenue cases.

At £30,000 of annual bookings, an Airbnb has very little tolerance for expensive management, financing and repairs. Around £40,000-£45,000, the economics become much more interesting. Above £50,000, a legally secure property can still be a very strong short-term-rental asset.

The table below is an illustrative operating model rather than a market forecast. We assume 20% management, which matches the advertised fee of one established Edinburgh management company, plus another 10% of revenue for platform fees, utilities, insurance, maintenance, consumables and other operating costs. Cleaning can sometimes be largely passed through to guests, so its treatment varies by property.

Gross bookings	Operating costs at 30%	Income before financing and tax	Margin before financing and tax
£30,000	£9,000	£21,000	70%
£40,000	£12,000	£28,000	70%
£50,000	£15,000	£35,000	70%
£60,000	£18,000	£42,000	70%

Are Edinburgh property prices still low enough for Airbnb to work?

Yes, Edinburgh purchase prices can still support attractive Airbnb returns, although the result depends enormously on whether the property can legally earn short-term-rental income.

ESPC's latest figures put the average Edinburgh selling price at £310,332. Flats averaged £270,593 and houses £414,458. Edinburgh flats were still 2.4% more expensive than a year earlier.

Now compare the average flat price with several Airbnb revenue levels. £30,000 of gross bookings equals 11.1% of a £270,593 purchase price. £40,000 gives 14.8%, while £50,000 gives 18.5%.

Those are revenue yields rather than profit yields, so they should never be compared directly with a conventional rental yield. Management, Airbnb fees, utilities, maintenance, tax, financing and periods when the property is unavailable all come out afterwards.

Even so, the gap is wide enough to explain why Edinburgh Airbnb remains attractive to established operators. A property capable of producing £40,000-£50,000 of annual bookings has plenty of revenue relative to a £270,000-£300,000 asset value.

The trap is buying the yield before verifying the use. A £270,000 flat that cannot obtain planning permission has an Airbnb revenue yield of zero.

How much extra does it cost to buy an Edinburgh Airbnb as a second property?

The 8% Additional Dwelling Supplement makes buying an Edinburgh Airbnb noticeably more expensive before furnishing or renovation even begins.

For buyers who already own another dwelling and fall within the ADS rules, Scotland charges the supplement on the full purchase price alongside normal Land and Buildings Transaction Tax.

Take the latest £270,593 average Edinburgh flat. Ordinary LBTT comes to roughly £3,130. The 8% supplement adds another £21,647, bringing the property transaction taxes to about £24,777.

At Edinburgh's £310,332 overall average selling price, ordinary LBTT is roughly £5,117 and ADS about £24,827. Together they approach £30,000.

That upfront cost changes the investment yield. If somebody buys the average Edinburgh flat for £270,593 but pays nearly £24,800 in LBTT and ADS, the capital committed is already close to £295,400 before solicitors, mortgage fees, furniture or compliance work.

An Edinburgh Airbnb can earn enough to absorb that cost over time. A mediocre one will take years simply to recover the acquisition taxes.

Purchase price	Standard LBTT	8% ADS if applicable	Total transaction tax
£200,000	£1,100	£16,000	£17,100
£250,000	£2,100	£20,000	£22,100
£270,593	~£3,130	~£21,647	~£24,777
£310,332	~£5,117	~£24,827	~£29,943

Did the end of the furnished-holiday-let tax regime hurt Edinburgh Airbnb profits?

Yes, the removal of the UK's furnished-holiday-let tax regime made Edinburgh Airbnb ownership less attractive, particularly for individual owners using debt.

HMRC ended the special FHL treatment from April 2025. Holiday-let owners lost a set of advantages that previously separated qualifying short-term rentals from normal residential property businesses.

One important change concerns mortgage interest. Under the former FHL regime, qualifying owners had more favourable treatment of finance costs. Individuals now fall under the usual residential-property finance-cost rules, where relief is generally given through a basic-rate tax reduction instead of simply deducting mortgage interest from rental profit in the old way.

The old FHL treatment also offered access to capital allowances on qualifying equipment, some capital-gains reliefs associated with trading businesses and treatment of profits as relevant earnings for pension purposes. Those advantages have gone.

This hits leveraged individual owners harder than cash buyers. It also means that two Edinburgh Airbnbs with identical revenue can produce very different after-tax returns depending on debt levels and ownership structure.

Does Airbnb's new fee structure reduce Edinburgh host profits?

Airbnb's move toward a 15.5% host-paid single service fee can squeeze Edinburgh hosts who fail to reprice, although much of the change can be offset by adjusting the advertised nightly rate.

Airbnb is currently moving UK hosts from its older split-fee structure toward a single host fee. Under the old model, many hosts paid roughly 3% while guests separately paid a service fee. Under the single-fee structure, most affected hosts pay 15.5% from their payout, with Airbnb showing the guest a cleaner all-in accommodation price.

The percentage looks like a huge new cost if we compare 15.5% with the old 3% host fee in isolation. That comparison misses the guest fee that previously sat on top of the host's advertised rate.

Airbnb's own example explains the economics neatly. Under the older system, a host setting £100 could earn around £97 while the guest saw roughly £115. Under the single-fee version, the host can instead set approximately £115, the guest still sees £115 and the host again receives around £97 after the 15.5% deduction.

Hosts therefore need to think in terms of the customer's final price rather than simply increasing their old nightly rate by 15.5%. In a market where Edinburgh ADR and RevPAR are already slightly lower, operators have less freedom to pass every cost increase straight through to visitors.

Does Edinburgh's 5% visitor levy make Airbnb much less profitable?

The new Edinburgh visitor levy raises the guest's final bill, but it does not automatically remove 5% from the host's Airbnb revenue.

The levy now applies across the entire city to paid overnight accommodation, including short-term lets. It is charged at 5% of the accommodation cost before VAT and only applies to the first five consecutive nights.

For example, £200 per night for three nights creates a £30 levy. A five-night stay at the same accommodation price creates £50. On a ten-night booking, the levy still stops after the first five nights.

The host collects and accounts for the charge, but economically the important question is whether guests tolerate the higher final price. A host who can maintain a £200 base rate while the visitor pays the levy keeps the same accommodation revenue. If the final bill becomes too expensive and the host has to cut the base rate to stay competitive, part of the levy effectively comes back through lower pricing.

Edinburgh has an advantage here because every major form of paid visitor accommodation in the city faces the same levy. Airbnb is therefore not being singled out against hotels.

Still, the levy arrived just as Airbnb's average Edinburgh daily rate was already down 5.8%. Hosts should not assume customers have unlimited room for another increase in the final checkout price.

Can an Edinburgh Airbnb still beat a normal long-term rental?

A strong legal Edinburgh Airbnb can still beat a long-term tenancy by a wide margin on gross revenue, but the advantage shrinks quickly once we include management, financing, tax and the extra work involved.

The basic attraction is easy to see. AirDNA's current average annual revenue figure is around £41,500. Even if we haircut that number rather than accepting it blindly, a successful short-term let can produce revenue far above what many ordinary Edinburgh flats collect from a twelve-month tenant.

Airbnb also lets an owner capture Edinburgh's extreme August pricing and adjust rates around festivals, rugby weekends, Christmas, Hogmanay and other high-demand dates. A conventional landlord cannot reprice the same property several times a week.

Long-term letting has a much simpler cost structure. There are fewer turnovers, less cleaning, fewer consumables, lower management intensity and no need to constantly optimise nightly pricing. The owner also avoids the same secondary-let planning hurdle.

That means the comparison changes by property. A legally protected Airbnb capable of £45,000 or £50,000 of bookings has a strong chance of producing more cash than a conventional tenancy. At £25,000-£30,000, particularly with outsourced management and a mortgage, much of the short-term-let premium can disappear.

We would want a meaningful revenue gap before accepting all the extra complexity. Beating long-term rent by a few thousand pounds is not enough.

Who can still make good money with Airbnb in Edinburgh?

The best Edinburgh Airbnb opportunity today is an already legal property with strong visitor appeal, while highly leveraged buyers hoping to convert an ordinary residential flat face a much weaker setup.

Established operators benefit from something new entrants do not have: scarcity. AirDNA says active listings have fallen 28.3% year on year. Once an owner has a compliant property with proven demand, that reduced supply can be valuable.

Self-managing owners also have an advantage. A 20% management charge consumes £8,000 on £40,000 of bookings before platform fees or other property expenses. Someone able to handle pricing, guest communication and operational oversight more efficiently keeps considerably more of the Airbnb premium.

Cash buyers face another easier equation because the abolition of FHL tax advantages hurts leveraged individuals more heavily. Owners of properties with private entrances, existing commercial characteristics or firmly established short-term-let use also avoid some of the planning uncertainty that makes a standard tenement conversion so dangerous.

The least convincing setup is almost the reverse: buy an ordinary shared-stair flat, pay ADS, take a large mortgage, outsource management and hope planning approval arrives afterwards. Edinburgh Airbnb economics are nowhere near forgiving enough for us to recommend that approach.

Is Airbnb still profitable in Edinburgh, then?

Yes, Airbnb is still profitable in Edinburgh, but we would now describe it as a scarce-permission business rather than an easy property strategy.

The underlying customer market remains excellent. Edinburgh still receives more than five million overnight tourism trips a year, platform short-term lets generate around three million guest nights, international visitors dominate the guest mix, AirDNA occupancy remains around 68%, and the Festival creates one of the strongest seasonal pricing opportunities in Britain.

Current operating data is less spectacular than the tourism story suggests. ONS guest nights slipped 1.4% in its latest comparable period. AirDNA has ADR down 5.8% and RevPAR down 6.1%. We see a mature, high-demand market where every host's revenue is not automatically climbing.

At the same time, active supply has fallen 28.3%. That helps explain why owning an established legal Edinburgh Airbnb can still be attractive. The city has plenty of visitors and fewer straightforward properties competing for them.

New buyers face the opposite side of that scarcity. Whole-home secondary lets normally need planning permission, shared-stair residential flats are difficult candidates, ADS can add more than £20,000 to a typical purchase, the FHL tax advantages have disappeared, Airbnb is shifting more hosts toward a 15.5% host-paid service fee, and visitors now pay Edinburgh's 5% accommodation levy.

Our conclusion is sharp. We would still consider buying an Edinburgh Airbnb when the short-term-let use is already legally secure and the property can realistically generate around £40,000 or more in annual bookings. We would be much more cautious about buying a normal residential flat and trying to create that permission afterwards.

Edinburgh still offers excellent Airbnb profits. What has become scarce is the right to access them.

Who is the author of this content?

INVESTROPA

A team specialized in real estate investing in European countries

We are a team of financial experts, legal professionals, developers, and local real estate specialists dedicated to helping people like you avoid mistakes when investing in real estate in a foreign place, particularly in Edinburgh. If you’d like to learn more about us, you can check our presentation page.